Print Page | Close Window

MTB 506

Printed From: BMPT Forum
Category: Boats (In alphabetical order)
Forum Name: Motor Torpedo Boats
Forum Description: Discussion on Motor Torpedo Boats
URL: http://www.bmpt.co.uk/forum_posts.asp?TID=276
Printed Date: 26 March 2026 at 8:57pm


Topic: MTB 506
Posted By: S R Wilson
Subject: MTB 506
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 4:18pm

OK guys things have progressed.

Happy to say that subject to the paperwork being completed The Old War Boat Company Ltd, which was formed only today following the meeting refered to elsewhere on this forum, has aquired 506 for preservation.

There is obviously a lot of work to do to get her back to the UK and restored. One of the group or more will be going to Malta shortly to sort out stablisation of the boat and what is required in the short term.

Obviously what we need immediatly is gearboxes and money not particularly in that order. Please send all donations to The Old War Boat Company Ltd c/o D C M Money Solutions 3 Hope Drive The Park Nottingham. NG7 1DL

Further posts when there is anything to report. Please don't take this post as anything more than brief information just so you know the boat won't be lost.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.




Replies:
Posted By: Christian
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 4:50pm

Hi Sentley

Best of British to you all! Let us all know which reduction boxes are required as soon as you know (perhaps C Morgan can provide this info) so that the rest of us can keep our eyes peeled. I think Ambra is an excellent choice, Dad and I are relieved she will be saved.

On a different note, the MASB is sold and will also return to the UK sometime this year. I am unable to disclose the buyer's name at this stage.

Should have quite a fleet there soon!

Rgds,



Posted By: johnk
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 5:14pm

Hi Sentley and Christian,

 

Just read the above, well done on both fronts, my "offer" of support remains to the new company if wanted, would love to see the MASB in the flesh so to speak, understand the buyer dose not want to be published, but would love to see her over here. Well, there it is, best of luck to all, looking forward to developements in the coming year.

John 



Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 6:56pm

 The gearboxes were borg warner if anyone has three going spare. Sorry dont know ratio. Should be set up for efficient cruising as its a long way & a lot of diesel. anyone know best ratio for this?

 If a joint scrounge for these, tools needed to fix her up, navigation & safety equipment could be palleted up & sent out great stuff. should b fun loading gearboxes from a rib onto Ambra in mid stream

 Will need some work on hull but told it was Raia that needed total refastening. Dont take that as gospel until she's been inspected.

  Congrats to 32's new owner. Guessing they'll be overrun with offers to crew her for the trip home. Bet you'll miss her Christian? Due credit to you & Hector for keeping her in fine shape.



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 7:08pm

Congratulations guys.



Posted By: d-zine
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 8:08pm

Wonderful News,

I was seriously concerned that we would lose yet another of the dwindling number of survivors. I won't be understating it when I say that I was heart broken to hear about Raia.

The best of British to you, keep everbody posted and I for one will help where I can (however limited that may be).

On another note it is brilliant news to her of 32's impending repatriation, well done to Christian and Hector.



-------------
Advance - Runaway Quickly , Runaway Quickly


Posted By: Christian
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 8:51pm

Hi All

Thanks for the kind words, Hector dedicated very much of his time to 32 and appreciates the sentiment. The boat will be missed a great deal by us all, she is a real survivor that one. 

Regarding the boxes for Ambra, the reduction (be they BW or PRM or whatever) will depend largely on what props she currently has (i.e. pitch and diameter, assume 3-bladed & handed). We can pretty much guess the other information needed to calculate the reduction (knowing the model of the engines would be handy, or at least max rpm). We have a neat little computer which will give us the desired reduction for optimum overall performance, i.e. allowing the engines to just achieve their max rpm at light load conditions (anything else will overload them). 

Rgds, 



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 9:50pm

Good Evening.

Thanks to you all for your knd wishes and offers of help. Please don't wait to be asked, to much help is better than not enough. Right now the priority is to build up a cash fund to get her fit to bring back to the UK. We take cash cheques IOUs and credit/debit cards.

Seriously though real thanks for the good wishes and I repeat them to Christian and his Dad and the lucky buyers of 32. Christian we will take you up on the use of your computer program in due course.

Just think guys if we could get 102 32 and 506 on the same piece of water at the same time, I think I would cry!!!

Regards



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 14 February 2007 at 11:11pm

CONGRATULATIONS   to the Old warboat company.

If you could confirm that the gearboxes are borg warner and let me know the reductions(if any) then I will have a look, I could lend a couple until the summer or donate depending on what I have got, I doubt I will have three of any but should have at least one of one sort (if that makes sense) How many engines will you need for the trip (1,2 or 3) I assume that you have backplates?

  Regarding the news of 32, this is especially good for me as Hector has agreed that I should be her next custodian.she will be returning to uk in the summer and will reside in Norfolk for the foreseeable future, as with d-zine I will be keen to let people know what will be going on but I doubt that there will be much news until autumn time.

 This is also a good time to express my  sincere thanks to Christian and especially Hector for their hospitallity, congratulate Christian on such a superb home built model collection, and Hector for showing me his impressive collection of photos/literature on coastal craft.(and cars!)

The Plan is to have her skippered home, I will not do this myself as she will be returning by sea (not canal) and I have not got a clue how to navigate!(yet) I have a couple of contacts which I will pass on to the old warboat co if they do not DIY!

Excellent news for us all,

  Rergards,  Clive..



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 1:17am

 Engines are 2x 180hp ford 6cyl & 1 perkins 6534 if it helps work out boxes. Assuming theres backplates as regularly started & starter gotta go somewhere.

 Somebody buy the other Gibraltar boats & we can bring home a flottilla . What a sight that'd be.

 Congrats Clive! What a beauty. Still trying to sort myself to look at 56



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: johnk
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 7:59am

Hi All,

Well, what a lot going on! congrats to Clive on 32, Norfolk eh, "joining" 102 good company. Re 506, chatting with a friend who dose know about these things, he said he would be concerned that having the gear boxes out could strain the hull,  ie such lumps not being there. Not much choice as done by the owners, but this would need as with all else checking out. Early days and first things first, but is the Old War Boat Co thinking of other projects perhaps,  another force for trying to save more of our coastal craft before its all to late. As ever, all the best,

 

Regards

 

John    



Posted By: Garethep
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 10:50am
Hi all, congratulations on making something happen! Ill draw dads attention to this thread and he should be able to let you know what gearboxes Are fitted to Hyperion Which may help for the perkins (centre shaft i assume). I also believe that the ford engines were used in many fairey Power boats and he knows a man who knows those boats. I think it unlikely that the removal of the boxes will have caused any further hull damage, even if the originals were structural the replacements almost certainly not. They would also be Very small and ligh in comparison to the originals. I hope the following doesnt lead anyone to conclude im an expert im these things but ill throw im my opinion anyway. Hyperion handles very badly on the centre shaft only and i see no reason why 506 would be any better. For this reason as well as lack of power i would not advise a delivery on one shaft. Even on three engines you wont get 'on the step' even if the hull could take it . My gut feeling is you would be best using the outer shafts only and keeping the centre engine to run an alternator and a bilge Pump. You should get 8-10 knots which is a comfortable delivery speed and minimise hull stress. just a couple of thoughts, best of luck.   Gareth


Posted By: BMPT
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 10:54am

Good morning Sentley,

Well done with regard to 506.

I would be cautiuous bringing her back by sea, a long way for an old lady, but all the best anyway. Visited her 2 years ago, ..

Could you give a brief synopsis of the situation and your needs, and I will put in the BMPT News section, with direct link to the 506 site.

Will the company have a web site...?

If so give me the link, it may get some more interested partries looking at you..

 

Kind regards

 

Richard Hellyer

BMPT 023 8089 0900.



Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 7:36pm

Hi,

  I had a look today and I have 2x 1:1 borgwarner 'boxes mounted on some hl 6534's which I would be willing to split and donate to the cause if they are the correct boxes, I also have about five other borgwarners with reductions which would need to be checked, one of which I know is 2:1. I have some 'tested' boxes too, but as with all the reduction boxes would only be willing to 'lend' them for the trip as they are effectively 'essential spares' for me.

  When the call is made to establish the prop sizes may I suggest that you ask wether the 'drive plates' are still in place.

I assume that you have someone to fit them the other end? I recon it would be cheaper to pay someone that end than fly someone out with tools.

 Please keep us posted as to wether someone can be found to do this job as  although in no way do I have time to do this job with all other things I have to do in the next few months, I have the tools and have done this job a few times before and appreciate that 506 may have less time.

javascript onClick=window.close - Close Window


-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 8:40pm

Evening All,

Please forgive me if I don't reply straight away to individule posts of help etc. Hope you understand that having stood back so as not to pre empt our friends from Canada we have had to move very quickly on some real basics and still have not sorted everything but :-

1. I am logging all offers of help etc and will get in touch with everyone in due course.

2. In general terms a number of us will be going to Malta over the next few weeks and months to look at the boat and work on her

3. As soon as there is anything to report of general interest it will be posted, hopefully with photo

4. We really do appreciate your good wishes which have done much to prove that in an insane world we are amongst the few sane people on this planet!!



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: Christian
Date Posted: 15 February 2007 at 9:12pm

My friend Eric in Malta has come up with the following useful contacts for you;

 

The Captain Morgan Cruises Offices and Boats are all found a stone's throw away from Manoel Island Yacht Yard, where I believe the boat may be stored for some time. (See  http://www.yachtyard-malta.com/ - http://www.yachtyard-malta.com/ )
 
==================================================
 
Regarding a shipwright or marine surveyor, I have checked on the net and found two that may be of help.
 
There is O.F. Gollcher & Sons Ltd., of Valletta, Malta (see  http://www.gollcher.com/main.htm - http://www.gollcher.com/main.htm ) are a very old family in this business and I believe, highly reputable.  Their contact details are the following.
 
O.F. Gollcher & Sons Ltd., (Head Office).
P.O. Box 268,
19 Zachary Street,
Valletta - VLT 10,
Malta G.C.
 
Tel:    (+356) 2569 1500
Fax:   (+356) 2123 4195
 
Web:      http://www/gollcher.com - http://www/gollcher.com
E-mail    mailto:contact@gollcher.com - contact@gollcher.com

Regards,

Christian.



Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 6:47am

Just putting a pic up for the benefit of anyone who's followed threads i've put on a couple of other forums. This is her working for southern television.

 Amazing what you find, just read an article about 3 abandoned type xxi uboats. Project anyone?

 Cheers for imfo Christian.

 

 



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 11:49am

Hi Clive and Christian.

Clive, have you any idea of the weight of the boxes please. We would like to take up your offer. Some of the guys are going out there shortly to make an assesment etc and we will contact you againg when we have more information. Very many thanks.

Christian, Thanks for the info which will undoubtly be very usefull. i will get the guyds to make contact once they are there.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 12:28pm
Hi Jimmy,
Which article was this in?  Any more details?

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 12:39pm

jimmy,

Re U boats. Why would anyone want to restore them just for us to blow them up (again)



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 1:10pm
Is this the correct model for the BRB 500 series or is it from a late '400' boat?
Thanks







-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 1:25pm

Help needed with Pennant Numbers....


I've searched all my books and can find very little reference top these BPB MTB '500' class.  MGB's assigbed these numbers were Dog boats (blocade runners mainly) and the Osprey book "British Motor Torpedo Boat 1939-45" says that  MTB's  Pennant No's 501 to 508 were assigned to Camper and Nicholson craft of 1941.

A Lt. Edge RNVR  won a DSC for an action with E-boats 24.10.43 (in company with a craft commanded by Lt Lightoller RNVR) .   It's likely this was won on MTB506 as he was her C.O. during at the time.

L.C. Reynold's excellent book "Home Waters MTB's and MGB's'  doesn't mention the action above, Lt Edge or any BPB 500 craft.

Could these craft have been reassigned the 500 series pennant numbers later in their careers?

Help...!!



Posted By: Garethep
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 1:50pm
Should have added to my last post. I'm currently enjoying a couple of months of very little work commitments. I'm more than happy to give up time to help in whatever way helps most.
Cheers
Gareth


Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 2:28pm

Hi Sentley,

I have just weighed the 'boxes,

with reduction boxes 60kg

without reduction 42kg.

 remember to add packing to weight, also the weight with reduction 'box may be a couple of kgs either way as my scales were on their second time round the dial!



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 2:31pm

Clive ,

Thanks. Will get back to you in early course.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: marksaab
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 4:36pm

Wow things have moved on quickly!

Although I'm only a newbie myself I am certainly up for working on 506 in Malta, if you can post some dates when you are flying there it would be helpful. Practical experience limited but very willing, fairly fit and usually free every other weekend!

Looks like return flights to Malta can be had for around £100!

Just a thought, my brother was on the C4 programme "no going back" a few years ago, RDF media seemed very happy to send film crews all over the Med/Canaries to film the progress of a yacht they were delivering, has anyone thought about talking to the TV people about this project? Something along the lines of "Epic return of the last MTB!" etc, I would be happy to make a couple of calls, no harm in asking I suppose?

Mark



-------------
Only yield when you must, never "give up the ship," but fight on to the last "with a stiff upper lip!"


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 5:24pm
Hi Mark,
Great idea. You should speak to Sentley as he is talking to a few people along those lines. The more conacts the better.

The more people involved in this project the better.

Cheers

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: marksaab
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 5:56pm

Hi Don

Good stuff! I just e.mailed someone I met at RDF last year asking for "directions" to people to pitch ideas too, hopefully should get some info back.

I will PM Sentley too.

On the project "suppliers" side of things I know a few very practical, switched on but very reasonable metal machining companies, i.e. give them a rusted lump and they will make a new one no drawings etc needed, one them was just filmed for another C4 TV programme.    

Oops looks like Sentleys mailbox is already full!!

Regards

Mark  

 



-------------
Only yield when you must, never "give up the ship," but fight on to the last "with a stiff upper lip!"


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 9:17pm

Hi Mark,

Have pm ed you to avoid embarresing anyone untill tings are finalised.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: CCFT
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 10:44pm

Toronto

16 Feb 07

Hi Jimmy,

Where did you read about the three Type XXIs?  Are they ones buried in the old sub bunker in Kiel?

Thanks,

Nicholas (CCFT)



-------------
Lt(N) Nicholas CM Armstrong


Posted By: CCFT
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 10:48pm

Toronto

16 Feb 06

Hello Don,

That scan is of the model of MTB 467 (now the houseboat Platypus at Hayling Island).  It is made by Dean's Marine and is quite good, but very expensive - the CCFT has bought one to use for display.

Aye,

Nicholas, CCFT



-------------
Lt(N) Nicholas CM Armstrong


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 11:15pm
http://www.uboat.net/flotillas/bases/kiel_bunkers.htm - http://www.uboat.net/flotillas/bases/kiel_bunkers.htm


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 11:16pm

http://bbs.keyhole.com/ubb/showthreaded.php?Number=276357 - http://bbs.keyhole.com/ubb/showthreaded.php?Number=276357

 



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 16 February 2007 at 11:52pm
Thanks for the reply Nicholas.  Is she the same type as BPB MTB 506 ?

I've put up a question about the 500 series BPB boats and their pennant nos but I've had no reply yet.

Cheers

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: CCFT
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 4:44am

Toronto

16 Feb 07

Hi Don,

I know that a few of the low 500 numbers were assigned to Dog boats, but then there boats like 505-509, 522 & 598 that were BPC 71.5' MTBs.  My reference books are packed away at the moment, but I'll see if I can dig up my Conway's which has a very good section on Coastal Forces craft.

As far as I know, MTB 467 would be more or less identical to 506.  The scuttles would probably be the only difference between the two boats.

Hope this is of help. 

Cheers,

Nicholas

CCFT



-------------
Lt(N) Nicholas CM Armstrong


Posted By: Pioneer
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 9:11am

Don

I tried to reach you via PM but your box is full.

501 - -504 were War builds (but just) and up for sale in 1945-1948. 505 - 509 were renovated into the Proud Class (when the differences in the Scuttles- as mentioned by CCFT - could have be made -I have their names and numbers if you so wish) 519,522 596 and 598 completed the Proud class - the whole class went into the Reserve Fleet at Felixtow for several years (early -mid 50's) other 500's were converted to CT's (Control Target) I also have their numbers if you so wish. At least 4 of the Proud's were purchased by Wessex Power Units and converted to Gas Turbine propulsion (506 - Proud Grenadier - Southerner - Ambra as well documented)

Some 500 series MGB's were as you say Camper Nicholson designs, including the 4 Registered Merchentmen on the ball bearing runs - the D Fairmiles that were briefly in that series soon were to be renumbered in the 50xxx series

Hope this helps

Ted



-------------
Pioneer - Forum Moderator


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 10:46am
Thanks Nicholas and Ted.   So I can take 467 as a 'base' model  and that 501-504 came after 506.  Is this correct?

I'ts strange but in about 8 reference books I looked in, there is no mention of Lt Edge or 506 OR his DSC.... Strange..


I'd appreciate the names of any reference books you've used to glean this information as my library has obviously been found lacking ...lol!

Thanks again.

(mailbox now cleared a bit)


-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: Pioneer
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 11:26am

Hello Don

The '500's' were part of an order made in 1943 - up to 508 they were only  completed in 1945 (inc 506) - 509 - part of the same order was completed in 1946. So 506 never saw much (if any) of the War. Lt Edge may have won his DSC in an earlier boat as 506 was not completed until 31st May 1945

Ted



-------------
Pioneer - Forum Moderator


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 12:45pm
Thanks Ted. 
I eventually found the BPB production records in appendix 3  of "Fast Boats and Flying Boats" which concur with what you say.

The MTB boats completed in the quarter to June 45 were MTB's 490-497 AND  499-506.

We had the history of MTB 506 from

        http://www.unithistories.com/officers/RNVR_officersE.html


Edge,
Patrick Noel Green "Pat"
P.N.Gge
?
-
T/Lt.
?
Officer of the Order of the British Empire OBE (civ)
01.01.1963
New Year 63

Distinguished Service Cross

DSC
08.02.1944
action with E-boats 24.10.43
Mention in Despatches MID
01.01.1942
New Year 42
Mention in Despatches MID
31.03.1942
action with battle cruisers12.02.42
Mention in Despatches MID
14.11.1944
Operation Neptune
(1942)


MASB 23
(10.1943)


CO MGB 609
16.08.1943
-
(06.1944)
CO HM MTB 506 (motor torpedo boat)
(1944)


Staff ACNXF
(1963)


councellor employment of the disabled


Obviously incorrect regards MTB506.   Strange though that the site has a  Charles Ortzen Abbott as on  MTB 504  from 5.03.1943 to 06.1944?  Again probably a typing error.


Thanks again


-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: rozm2
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 3:57pm
Congratulations on MTB 506, brilliant choice of boat for a group and will be quite a begining to get it back from Malta! May I ask who the group consists of, am I right that this was as a result of the meeting set up a week or two back?


Posted By: Pioneer
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 4:55pm

Don

Lt Edge's DSC was won while CO of 'D' boat 609 in 1943. The action - against e-boats - is described in "Dog Boats at War" - That web site that you quoted from is 'incorrect' in a few other areas but, on the whole, a valuable site for research (providing you double check)

Regards

Ted



-------------
Pioneer - Forum Moderator


Posted By: CCFT
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 5:25pm

Toronto

17 February 2007

 

Hi Don,

I’ve finally dug up my copy of Conway’s, All The World’s Fighting Ship’s, 1922-1946.  According to them, all the BPC MTBs of this class were numbered (as MTBs) 412-418, 430-432, 434-500, 502-509 & 519-522.  The later boats were possibly launched after 1946 and thus are not covered by this volume. 

I was wrong about the low 500s as only MTB 501 was not a member of this class, being a one-off experimental design by Camper & Nicholson.  I had a scan of a Dog boat incorrectly identified as MTB 502.  The mistake may be due to the fact that MGB 502 was one of those strange MGBs that were built for Turkey with diesel engines, some of which were converted for blockade runners with the bridge situated quite far aft, but with a hull of about the same dimensions as a Fairmile D.

Hope this helps.

Aye, 

Nicholas

CCFT  



-------------
Lt(N) Nicholas CM Armstrong


Posted By: Pioneer
Date Posted: 17 February 2007 at 8:21pm

My List of the refurbished BPB Co boats in question.

MTB 505

P1505

Proud Fusilier

MTB 506

P1506

Proud Grenadier

MTB 507

P1507

Proud Guardsman

MTB 508

P1508

Proud Highlander

MTB 509

P1509

Proud Knight

MTB 519

P1519

Proud Lancer

MTB 522

P1522

Proud Legionary

MTB 596

P1596

Proud Patriot

MTB 598

P1598

Proud Patroller

 

British Power Boat Co refits.

“Proud Class”

 

“Radio Control Target

 

"Radio Control Target Boats”

MTB 457

?

P8201

MTB 480

P1588

P8204*

MTB 481

CT 46

P8202

MTB 488

P1588

P8205*

MTB 490

CT 49

MTB 521

P1521

P8203

* Expendable Targets (Janes 1957)

 

 

 

CAMPER AND NICHOLSON MGB’s 502 - 509

Length, o.a.

117 ft 0 in.

Beam

20 ft 3 in.

Draught, mean

4 ft 1 in.

Displacement

95 tons

Propulsion*

3 x Paxman VRB engines

Total output*

3000 bhp

Speed*

28 knots (max)

25 knots (continuous)

Complement

21

Endurance

2000 miles at 11 knots

 

 

*MGB 509 was powered by three Packard supercharged petrol engines giving a total output of 4050 bhp and speeds of 31 knots (max), 27 knots (continuous).

The remainder were powered by 3 x 12 cylinder Paxman Diesels

 

502

Completed as MGB, became MGB 2002 in 1945.

 

503

Completed as MGB, became MGB 2003 in 1945.

 

504

Completed as HOPEWELL, became MGB 504 in 1944 and MGB 2004 in 1945.

 

505

Completed as NONSUCH, became MGB 505 in 1944 and MGB 2005 in 1945.

 

506

Completed as GAY VIKING, lost 5/2/45 returning from Sweden to UK, operation "Moonshine".

 

507

Completed as GAY CORSAIR, became MGB 507 in 1944, and MGB 2007 in 1945. Stranded and foundered off Aberdeen 24/5/45.

 

508

Completed as MASTER STANDFAST, captured by German forces on 2/11/43 during "Operation Bridford".

 

509*

Completed as MGB 509, became MGB 2009 in 1945. Converted to gas turbine propulsion (centre shaft) in 1947 (the ‘Gatric’ experiment)

(this list shows 5 ((not 4)) boats completed as Merchantmen)

MTB 510 Vosper Experimental Craft.

There was an MTB 510. This was an experimental Vosper built ‘long boat’, similar to the Fairmile ‘D’ at 100ft 6ins l.o.a. Beam 19ft 6ins. Draught 5ft 6ins. Powered by 4 Packard Engines on two Shafts only.

 



-------------
Pioneer - Forum Moderator


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 18 February 2007 at 12:55am
Thanks Guys,
That clears it up. How confusing are those numbers!!

Regarding  506, some of us hope to go out next week and get this project physically started.   The goal is to get, and keep,  506 safe until we get the restoration plan in place.

By the way, I've been informed that there are still a bunch of old boats out there that may be of interest,  I'll bring a camera!!

Thanks to everyone for your help so far.

Cheers
Don





Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 18 February 2007 at 1:49am

 Well done Don! Things quiet workwise or would go there myself. If things pick up then good for a couple of months 'working holiday'

 Nicholas & his group in Canada still looking for a boat so any ideas for them? Thought about dismantling 145 into a shipping container as the cost would be a lot less to them than shipping a whole boat & the savings may be worth the extra hours.

 Its good to know that so many of us are willing to take positive action to save these historic craft when the time for talk is well and truly over for some.

 Its time to "stand up & be counted".

 If we fail to learn from history we are condemmed to make the same mistakes again!



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 18 February 2007 at 6:31am

 Re. my uboat post

 There are 3 buried in the Elbe2 bunker & another at i think kiel.

 Restoring one would be a multimillion pound project but worth grabbing as a display piece if it never goes to sea. History is written by the victors & we are obliged to buck the trend of religion & tell both sides of the story! Not a nazi sympathiser but most germans were good people in an impossible situation back then.

If you want a good one Argentina is probably the place to look

 History is a double edged sword, forget one side & you condemm yourself to make the same mistakes again



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 18 February 2007 at 11:23am

Haven’t you seen the German ww2 u-boat in the u.k. in perfect condition? Sad to say it may be scraped soon. When it was found it had all the original crews effects aboard. Personally I think its one of the most historic and rare vessels in the world. And we are going to scrap it.



Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 18 February 2007 at 11:53am

U-Boat 534 was laid down in 1942 ( type IXC/40) and is notable that she did not suffer or inflict a single casualty on either side during the war. After the order to surrender was given she was seen to be heading out of the area. So was sunk buy a American liberator. All bar two of the crew survived. Due to her attempt at escape she was branded a gold smuggler and raised. After she was raised and found to be empty of gold she was loaned to the Birkenhead warship trust.

The trust is now closed and it is suspected that if a home is not found for the U-534 and the other ships in the trust then they will be scraped.



Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 1:30pm

Hi Guys,

I have found a b/w 1.91:1 l/h gearbox (the hard to find one!) it has a ford backplate and drive plate which is probably worth a couple of hundred quid.

The gearbox is a reasonable £800 and he recons shipping to malta may cost £150.(he used to export gardner diesels there) a  r/h 'box should be less as they are a lot more common and he is getting a cost for the two boxes with combined shipping.

This may be out of the price bracket for now, and I have got a r/h 2:1 'box (I think) but it is a start point for whoever else is looking.

Cheers,  Clive..



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 1:41pm

Clive,

Thanks for your efforts. Don and Garry are going to Malta this week. If there is no prospect of a box in Malta (which will save shipping) we will have it thanks.

Where is it located please.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 1:55pm

The trust is now closed and it is suspected that if a home is not found for the U-534 and the other ships in the trust.

 

Could not the Imperial War Musem be persuaded to take the boats on , at least in some temporary capacity till proper homes are found for them. I belive there is a Ton call mine countermeasures boat but what else is there. Any smaller boats, MTBs or similar?

 



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: d-zine
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 3:14pm
Sentley,

I had a conversation with the Commander of the Submarine Museum at Gosport  about 6 months ago, at the time I was trying to save HMS Waterwitch and I thought he might be able to help. He pointed out that the Warship Trust in BIRKENHEAD had just gone bust and he was struggling to home HMS ONYX( according to the NRHV she will move to Barrow in Furness), he was not optimistic that he would succeed and thought that the rest of the collection would not fair any better.
I think HMS PLYMOUTH has found a new home on the southcoast to commemorate the Falklands War. Maybe "tonclass" would be able to update us on HMS BRONNINGTON although I think that her future is not yet secure.

So to sum it up things probably don't look that good for U-534 I cannot find any recent information only that she is/was owned by Danish company Den Bla Avis, which retrieved it from the sea-bed after it was sunk in World War II

-------------
Advance - Runaway Quickly , Runaway Quickly


Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 3:39pm

Hi Sentley,

 I'll pm you the details when he gets back to me, he is finding the other 'box and costing the shipping. I'll also visit the 'man across the road' who reconditions them.

could the centre box not be coupled to the r/h engine or will the hull take the speed/ power of the 3 engines?

I will also ask the skipper who will be bringing masb home wether he would be interested in a trip from Malta. I don't know what your thoughts are on how to get her home.

Regards,  Clive



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 4:25pm

Clive,

Thanks.  If 506 and the MA/SB came in convoy that might be something to see! I have pmed you.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: rozm2
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 4:35pm

Post moved to Birkenhead thread



Posted By: marksaab
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 7:00pm

Hi Sentley

Just a thought ref engines and gearboxes, i came across this site recently. I guess they well known to the group?

http://www.woods-group.co.uk/engines.htm - http://www.woods-group.co.uk/engines.htm

Maybe they would be interested in lending some support? 

Mark



-------------
Only yield when you must, never "give up the ship," but fight on to the last "with a stiff upper lip!"


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 7:03pm
Nice one Mark.

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: David Earle-Pay
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 8:16pm
re: gear boxes, according to the man that does a lot with Fairey's, the usual boxes used are 2:1's on the Ford engines (2:1.5 on the smaller versions) he has several available but in particular he has two fully servced units for £400 each. He refers to them as 72's but I dont know manufacturer however the three I have on 'Hyperion' are marked as 72's so the assumption is that they are the same and would also suit the Perkins 6354. Will try to get more infomation from him when he has more time if required. Regards David. typing error should read 1.5:1 on smaller versions

-------------
David Earle-Payne
Make it idiot proof, and then someone will make a better idiot!


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 19 February 2007 at 8:21pm
Hi David,
I'm sure you've seen this but I'll repeat it just in case. Nicholas from CCFT was told that she is missing a set of handed Borg Warner 72 boxes  Ratios: Left hand 1.9:1 and right hand 2.1:1.

I know nothing about these but your man's price seems very fair.

Gary & I'll find out as much as we can when we get there. We'll only have one day unfortunately.

Cheers

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 22 February 2007 at 11:47pm

Hi All,

Just a quick update on our visit to see Ambra/506 in Malta. I'm sure Gary will want to add to these comments as I've probably missed loads.

Photos athttp://www.rania.co.uk/boat%20photos/506 - www.rania.co.uk/boat%20photos/506

First let me say than we know but a little about DD/TD construction. We did a 60 minute tour of the boat and our look was pretty superficial.

There is a (big) problem with the port bottomside planking but let me leave that till last. The best bits first....

Decks:

The decks are ply sheathed and painted. The deck just aft of coachhouse is raised ply and possibly ply on top of original planking. The same is true of the deck just forward of the coachhouse. Paint seemed good and no sign of water ingress that I could see. We walked the decks and they felt really solid. No movement detected. From below deckbeams seemed sound too. Decks have simple seating fixed up fwd and open at back. Electric capstan fitted but not connected. Some original deck fittings still in place.

Superstructure:

Wood/ply construction. Very sound for what she is. Roof took our weight no problem and no obvious problems noticable. Old sign says 8 people max.

Mechanics:

3 engines fitted, 2 ford turbocharged 6-cylinder engines and one Perkins. Perkins on the button and sounded great. The mechanic swears that the Fords are great (and they looked in pretty good condition). Perkins has a gearbox but no shaft/prop. We're checking iof the old one from Raia is available to fit ( it's likely it is). The Fords are (as we know) missing gearboxes but the bellhousings are in place. There is a 12.5KV diesel generator working. Looks like a BMC engine but didn't investigate too closly as she was running. Original wheel in wheelhouse and Morse controls used for throttles/gears. The 220v system uses old style fuseboxes and would need to be treated with respect. Fitting an RCD would be a good idea. Oh, she has 2x450 litre old diesel tanks.

Hull Topsides:

We got out to see her and the hull sides (looking from the tender) looked pretty good. A line of coachbolt heads is noticable between portholes and sheer strake. Sheer strake weathered a bit.  Some rust stains visible but not too bad.  Some mild steel fixings on top of framse need replacing.

Hull Bottomsides.

Starboard:

This side seemed fine (or as well as could be expected). The timber looked pretty good in the areas we looked.

Port:

Her biggest problem is is the port bottomside planking. If I seperate it into 3 equal length sections it might be easier to explain.

Starting aft in the engineroom, planking seemed OK in the 2 or 3 places I tried. Access wasn't great and I wasn't exactly dressed for it.

Midships, I noticed quite a few large sections of ply between some of the frames further aft, screwed from the outside. Presumably damaged timber underneath the ply but couldn't say for sure.

Up Forward, We couldn't get access to the chain locker to see the bottomside there but just aft of it ( about 6 foot from stem) to the widest part of in the hull the bottomside planking is shot, going back 6-9 feet. A key would easily push through the triple diagonal planking there, certainly for the first 5-6 feet from the chainlocker. Gradually got better as we went further aft.

Oh and the Beer taps are still fitted...

Conclusion.

Other than portside bottom planking issue and a brace of gearboxes she's a good honest boat needing the usual work. Kevin at Captain  Morgan's needs to know what we're doing before 28th Feebuary.

The way Gary & I left it is that Kevin is to take her up on the slip as planned (he has to keep ownership until then as he has to have her insured). We arrive there and take her over if we want her ( for 1 Maltese Lire) and she's ours, batteries are included.  If not... well best not go there.

We have to get her powerwashed/shafts/props cleaned and temporary repairs done to bottomside and antifouled etc. If we take her, we really need gearboxes, insurance and find someone to fit 12V bilge pumps (solar power charging batteries?). At the moment the 220v pumps are operated only when mechanic goes onboard, about 1 or 2 times a week. Most of the water is coming in from that weak section, port bottomside planking.

We perhaps need to speak to our friends in the CCFT and between us decide how we go forward with saving this boat.

Over to you guys for ideas....

 



Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:12am

What’s easiest. Obtaining two boxes for the fords or obtaining two boxes for the Perkins and acquiring another Perkins there?

Is there any way to obtain a template for the bell housing to see if its possible to make an adapter plate to fit any available g/box. Sorry if the questions are foolish as im speaking from an automotive mechanics point of view rather than a marine fitter( or what ever the preferred term is)

Are you thinking of making the hull sound, fitting back up pumps and leaving here there until boxes can be found?

Would taking a large amount of timber out from the uk be more expensive than sourcing locally?

Same for scrounging boxes ect from local sources.. Cheaper than from uk or not?

What sort of cost is it to ship goods out to there? Eg lets just say two engines and/or boxes are found ( cheep or free ) plus a large amount of s/hand timber (again cheep or free). Would it be cost effective to ship the lot over there?



Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:41am

Welcome back lads,

 Take it theres absolutley no planking left from Raia we could liberate? If 506 has soft spots then she'll have to be sorted in Malta by the sound of things.

Any joy with a shipwright out there? We need to work out how much a local yard can fix her for & compare it to Repairing ourselves.

 I'm assuming the gearboxes simply bolt in like any smaller marine or wagon box so that could be done pretty easy although v heavy.



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:42am

But all daydreaming aside id turn up give him, his cash, hire the slip for a few days, buy a lot of wbp 8mm ply and laminate/screw/bond the hell out of the bottom, say 3 layers of 8 mm ply..20 sheets will seal up 18ft off hull.

Not pretty but in the absence of funds to re-plank the lower hull it will keep her afloat.

Batteries plus a float switch and method of recharging will deal with what gets in.

solar is expensive here. .maybe cheaper there? Look for a HGV truck stop for cheep 12/24 v panels and converters.



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:46am

Photos from Malta at:

http://www.rania.co.uk/boat%20photos/506 - www.rania.co.uk/boat%20photos/506



-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 1:57am

One question,

“A key would easily push through the triple diagonal planking there, certainly for the first 5-6 feet from the chain locker. “

Do you mean all the way through? Or just one layer?



Posted By: rozm2
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 9:56am

Looks good to me, I think perhaps a, dare I say it 'bogde repair' with ply may be best to get her back, on the power side perhaps a wind generator may be enough, think also about something that will still be of use in the UK, wherever you plan to bring her back to, perhaps wind would be better from that pint of view, Great job though, If I wasn't so short of money I'd get involved!

 



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 10:42am
Hi All,

Re the  "Key" test, as she was in water and the plank in question was under water level, I didn't dare to try to see if it would go through all 3 layers.  I'm confident it wouldn't be hard to push through though.

Unfortunately Raia completely broken up and all traces are gone.

I didn't state the obvious in the email  but we (obviously) have thought about plying the hull and perhaps doubling the frames where  necessary.  We also thought about 12v solar panels/bilge pumps, drilling through the bottom ties in every frame (between each bulkhead ) to let bilge pumps share the load and reduce number of pumps required (about 14 frames in the bad section alone).  

What we actually need  is:

1).  2 x B/W gearboxes in Malta ready for fitting. Photos are on the web site  showing the mountings & bellhousings.  There are none available in Malta that we know of.

2).  Shaft/prop for number 3 engine (perkins)

3).  Locate a boatyard in the Med fairly close where she can be put on the hard and repaired fairly cheaply.  

4). Find and hire a local down there to keep an eye on her.

5). Money to pay for temp  repairs, hull survey, slippage  and Insurance.

6). Get more people involved in a practical way and help with items 1, 3, 4 and 5.

I'm speaking to Kevin  re No 2 as I think he has a prop of Raia that could be adapted maybe.
 
Anyone able to help with the item 1,3, 4 and 5?


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 10:54am

Welcom back Don and Garry.

Before we start talking about how to get things sorted, what's the best to do with the hull etc do you not think that we need to decide it we are goin to pay the sum of 1 Maltese Lire for what is essentially a good saveable boat.

I really don't know what we are waiting for the time for talking has long past and we nust do it or she is scrapped. Put up or shut up.

Sorry if that sound abrupt but today is the 22nd February. We have 1 week. After that forget it!!!!



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 10:59am

1. Has already been offered

2-4 Can only be done out there but we have contacts.

5 The Company I work for will stake us £20,000 max(terms and conditions apply) till we can raise money of our own.

6. The forum is awash with offers to go and help.

 



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 11:10am

Sounds like your more or less sorted!. If Kevin is taking her out of the water how about doing some repairs on his slipway, Also have you considered moving one of her wing shafts to the centre to get her mobile to save having to pay people for tows etc.

 P.s If your not there on the 28th then I will be!



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 11:34am

Don,

Is the meeting this weekend still at your place? When is it please.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:06pm
Yes, Sunday in the pm suit everyone?   I think Gary is away.
Cheers
Don


 

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:20pm
Fine by me. Suggest about 1pm.

-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:24pm
Ah..2pm may be better.   Kids gotta go to church at 12.
Cheers


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 12:28pm
Hi Sentley,

Just read your summary of the items I listed.   You understand the urgency so I think it best that we understand exactly what we're doing, who's doing it and when.

1). I said we needed 2 x B/W gearboxes in Malta ready for fitting as she can't travel under her own power.  I've obviously missed some messages.  Do I understand from your reply that that is in hand and you'll look after it?

Are they being shipped down there for fitting when she's on the slip?  When do they arrive? How much was it to ship them?
Do we need to club together to help pay for their shipping?

2).  Shaft/prop for number 3 engine (perkins)
As I said, I'm speaking to Kevin  re No 2 as I think he has a prop of Raia that could be adapted maybe.   I'll try to take care of that.

Re the temporary repairsd,  Kevin said that we wouldn't be allowed to work on the boat while she's on the slip.  We'll need get a n hourly rate from the yard for temp repairs.   She'll have to be off the slip by 20th (around then) as the boat in front of her will be coming back down the slip.


3).  Locate a boatyard in the Med fairly close where she can be put on the hard and repaired fairly cheaply.  

That should be done from here with a phone before we go down so there is a plan in place.  Can't really be done over there as we need to check yards in Sardinia/Sicily, maybe North Africa.   Kevin has no Contacts that can help and Joe  didn't think we could do it  without having someone local to look after the project - a surveyor perhaps.
 
4). Local to look after her.

I'll speak to Kevin and see if he can help locate someone to look after her for a short time at any rate.

5.  Money to pay for temp  repairs, hull survey, slippage  and Insurance.

We need insurance for her too.   The harbour will want someone local to monitor her and bail her out if she ships water.  I think the insurance mayl pay to lift her but there will be fines well over £2,000 if she sinks!!  We need to get that in place before the 28th preferably.

I guess if we have £3-5000 + insurance money we should be able to get her sorted on the day.  I can't see how we couldn't. Slipping is £1500 but we're hoping Captain Morgan will pay at least 50% as they would have to slip her to break her anyway.

6). Get more people involved in a practical way and help with items 1, 3, 4 and 5.    How is that being utilised and who is doing what?

Who is planning to go out when she's slipped and take her over for the nominal 1 Lire?   

It is important to understand that when we pay that 1 lire we have responsibility for her under Maltest law. That includes insurance and making sure that she is safe when she comes off the slip.

The reason we should wait until she is on the slip is that Captain Morgan's will hopefully pay that part and we have a surveyor look her over to see if she IS savable.    It also gives time to get insurance in place.

So as you quite rightly say, lets put up or shup up and lets get this thing moving and get these things done before the 28th.


Cheers

Don


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 1:05pm

I have already offered via dgray to go out there and look after her for a few weeks until you guys are ready to come out and start work. Cheaper than hiring a local as I will live aboard for nothing.



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 1:13pm

Don,

1.See posts by Clive and by David Earle-Pay. Not yet packaged as only this am found out can't get any in Malta. Have already made enquiries about cost ect of freight and hope to have the answer by Sunday. 2pm OK by the way. I am happy to organise this if thats's whats required

2. I assume you will deal with getting a rate for the temp repairs IF we cant find somewhere to do the job properly in Malta.

3. Has Christian got any contacts in that part of the world, otherwise we may be better off staying in Malta.

4. In the longer term yes but Jimmy is prepared to go and stay there in the short term.

5.I will sort the insurance and you know about the money already. Is anyone else prepared to do the same thing? Quite agree that we shold get all contributions we can from Captain Morgan. Can Joe not help with regard to the local(s) required?

6. I agree. I thought one of the things for Sunday was to decide who does what. As to who ownes the boat once the price is paid, the answer is The Old War Boat Company Limited Registered in England, Company Number 61080907. That way the is no personal liabilty unless the Directors KNOWINGLY act recklessly.

EVERYBODY

WE NEED PEOPLE TO GET INVOLVED, CASH, WORK OR ANYTHING. PLEASE PLEASE IF YOU CAN HELP PLEASE SAY WHAT YOU CAN DO AND WHEN YOU CAN DO IT.

We must save this boat.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 1:17pm

Justy seen NEU post. That will be 2 out there initially, NEU and Jimmy. Great.

Again I can't be there on 28th. Just starting new venture here, but I will get ther in the end.



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: johnk
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 1:56pm

Hi All,

 

Just read the above, you seem to have things either covered or are aware of things to be covered, I will take the plunge and forward something to you, not much sorry but something. If I may say so, I think getting a surveyor to do a report and go the full hog to say what would be needed to make her safe and seaworthy, perhaps thinking as I write, see what the insurance people would want to see before they would insure, if at all, and for how much. On the other hand, read in All at Sea paper from  a staff writer who engaged a surveyour twice and ended up with totally cr..p boats and went with gut instict once and was OK! so what dose that say. But seriously, I think working from the insurance view would be best perhaps. However, for now, getting her off the current owners and secure under the company ownership and then having the time to think and to organise would seem to be the immediate concern. If, and I know this would be a real downer, it dose not work out then at least not to much money has gone in, though of course I understand you have already put in time and money of course. Well, there it is, for what its worth. All the best,

 

John  



Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 2:15pm

Hello all,

 looks like the generator is a Perkins 4.108 (poss 4.107) also looks like at least 1 drive plate is missing (cant see the other but bell housing is attached so probably in there.

 I am no shipwright (obviously) but I assume with regard to the hull you will be doing 'get her home' repairs? I also appreciate that it is easier to rip off rotten wood than it is to replace with new (esp dd) but how about 18inch strips of 1/2inch marine ply doubled up and overlapped, also doubling up on some of the 'less solid' timbers.

It is probably worth remembering that however solid one man thinks his repair is, what really matters is wether a skipper will risk his ass bringing her home.. and with regard to the getting her home situation, has a quote been obtained for her as deck cargo? bear in mind 4-5k diesel and skipper+crew for 25-30 days as well as travelling costs, freight, insurance, slipping and mooring, also shipwright/ engineer (who are not voulenteers)

Sorry if this is all in hand, well worth doing the  sums though.

regards. Clive

 



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 2:31pm

Hi all

Insurance.

 Waiting to hear back but no one will give full cover without a survey and valuation.ce they are avaliable many variations on a theme. Am advise to do third party cover to start. That is cover for the cost of wreck removal etc so she can come off the slip at the required time. The harbour authorities will then be happy and we get time to get proper quotes. Should have figs by Monday.

John.

Thanks for that. Every penny is a real help and if it doesn't go ahead we will refund it.

Clive.

Shipping as deck cargo quotes all around the £20000+vat. Cheaper on her own keel, even if we have to have a full repair done in the Med. We will of course have to pay a Skipper. Any volanteers to crew her back?

Funny.

Asked one specilist boat broker for quote for "a WW2 MTB currently in Malta" Female reply "when was it built?" Bet she doesn't know JFK is dead either



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 3:12pm
Sentley,

Thanks for message.

1.See posts by Clive and by David Earle-Pay. Not yet packaged as only this am found out can't get any in Malta. Have already made enquiries about cost ect of freight and hope to have the answer by Sunday. 2pm OK by the way. I am happy to organise this if thats's whats required.

Has anything more concrete happened since Clive's kind offer and Davids info on the boxes.  I've probably missed messages so sorry if my information is out of date.

I just checked and found out 10 cubic feet is £650 door to door.  Possibly more than we need but I was guessing measurements.

2. I assume you will deal with getting a rate for the temp repairs IF we cant find somewhere to do the job properly in Malta.

I can try.

I was hoping somebody could  do the chasing up re the boatyards. I've had 3 days away with Malta and 3 setting up the site etc. I have to get back to some real work. 

3. Has Christian got any contacts in that part of the world, otherwise we may be better off staying in Malta.

Perhaps you could ask him as I don't know if he does.

4. In the longer term yes but Jimmy is prepared to go and stay there in the short term.

Great. We'll need to sort him a tender to get to her and back.

5.I will sort the insurance and you know about the money already. Is anyone else prepared to do the same thing? Quite agree that we shold get all contributions we can from Captain Morgan.

Sorry, having a senior moment here. I don't understand, "Prepared to do the same thing".   Insurance without survey may be very tricky. There are some 3rd party boat insurances that are rubbish and she must be covered if she sinks.   I'd hate to  imagine what lifting her would cost if she sank.

6. I agree. I thought one of the things for Sunday was to decide who does what. As to who ownes the boat once the price is paid, the answer is The Old War Boat Company Limited Registered in England, Company Number 61080907. That way the is no personal liabilty unless the Directors KNOWINGLY act recklessly.

Sunday is 2 days missed in which things could be happening.
I sent you a pm regarding the company.   'Recklessly' presumably would include,  insufficient insurance, boat not repaired properly for any journey undertaken etc....


Agree re people getting involved.  We need to get these issues sorted ASAP.

Have you heard from Alex and Jimmy. Are they arriving on Sunday?


Cheers


Posted By: northeastuser
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 3:37pm

Am I right in saying that they are hauling her up onto the slip to beak her? So he’s hired it from the 28th till the 20th? So as soon as she changes hands you have a debt re the time on the slip and re-launching?

Would it not be better to take her on before she gets slipped with 3rd party insurance and find a price yourself for a slip.? You could always swap the Perkins and box over for one of the ford engines without taking her out of the water to make her mobile.I would imagine she can move around the harbour on one prop. That way your not limited to the price in one yard.plus saving in towage fees.



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 3:55pm
Originally posted by dgray dgray wrote:

Sentley,

Thanks for message.

1.See posts by Clive and by David Earle-Pay. Not yet packaged as only this am found out can't get any in Malta. Have already made enquiries about cost ect of freight and hope to have the answer by Sunday. 2pm OK by the way. I am happy to organise this if thats's whats required.

Has anything more concrete happened since Clive's kind offer and Davids info on the boxes.  I've probably missed messages so sorry if my information is out of date.

I just checked and found out 10 cubic feet is £650 door to door.  Possibly more than we need but I was guessing measurements.

You have not missed anything. Now I know we need the boxes arrangments can be made to get them there but there was no point untill you had confirmed everything was as we understood it to be. Where shold the boxes shipped to?

2. I assume you will deal with getting a rate for the temp repairs IF we cant find somewhere to do the job properly in Malta.

I can try.

I was hoping somebody could  do the chasing up re the boatyards. I've had 3 days away with Malta and 3 setting up the site etc. I have to get back to some real work. 

We can deal with work responsibilities on Sunday. Will you be able to go to Malta again next week?

3. Has Christian got any contacts in that part of the world, otherwise we may be better off staying in Malta.

Perhaps you could ask him as I don't know if he does.

I have pmed Christian. No doubt he will come back to me as soon as he is able. 

4. In the longer term yes but Jimmy is prepared to go and stay there in the short term.

Great. We'll need to sort him a tender to get to her and back.

I understand he is a good swimmer!

5.I will sort the insurance and you know about the money already. Is anyone else prepared to do the same thing? Quite agree that we shold get all contributions we can from Captain Morgan.

Sorry, having a senior moment here. I don't understand, "Prepared to do the same thing".   Insurance without survey may be very tricky. There are some 3rd party boat insurances that are rubbish and she must be covered if she sinks.   I'd hate to  imagine what lifting her would cost if she sank.

"To do the same thing." That is to say to committ to an amount of money towards the project.

As you say the insurance will be tricky.As I have already said the only short term hope is third party insurance untill we have a survey and valuation. I am advised it will then take a week or so to get quotes.

We have to aquire the boat and responsibility for her while she is on the slip. Therefore when she goes back into the water she will be our responsibility. The only insurance avaliable in those circumstance, if any at all is third party. You are I assume quite right about the cost of raising her. If the insurance, the only sort that is avaliable won't cover that for some rason then the liability falls on the Company. The Company's only assett is the boat whch by then will be a liability so the Company would have to go into liquidation. The officers of the Company would have no Liability since thaey will have taken all reasonable steps.

6. I agree. I thought one of the things for Sunday was to decide who does what. As to who ownes the boat once the price is paid, the answer is The Old War Boat Company Limited Registered in England, Company Number 61080907. That way the is no personal liabilty unless the Directors KNOWINGLY act recklessly.

Sunday is 2 days missed in which things could be happening.
I sent you a pm regarding the company.   'Recklessly' presumably would include,  insufficient insurance, boat not repaired properly for any journey undertaken etc....

It is already 3.45 approx on Friday. So far as I am aware most of the people we need to deal with don't work over the weekend and we are trying, each of us, to get as much done before Sunday as possiable. I dont think the grass is being allowed to grow.

Recklessly means what it says. In any event see above


Agree re people getting involved.  We need to get these issues sorted ASAP.

Have you heard from Alex and Jimmy. Are they arriving on Sunday?

I believe Jimmy will be there on Sunday. I have not heard from Alex and Mark has asked to come along if he can get. i have pmed him your address.

Hope this is the info you were looking for.

BTW who did you get the transport costs from? I assume it was air freight.




Cheers

Regards



-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: S R Wilson
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 4:30pm
Air freight cost of both boxes door to door by DHL. Collect Monday deliver Wednesday next week £1094.

-------------
SRW
"Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy" WSC.



Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 4:35pm
Gearbox sent from leeds to Malta=£90 (part container)

-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 5:22pm

Can you pm me the address Don?

 I can swim ok but can the missing prop. I'll have a look to see where she could be moved to for fulltime repairs. Africa's cheap & thats where original timber came from(she might get pressed back into service in such a stable region though)

 If someone can also help look for somewhere to put her great, all hands to the pumps so to speak.

 I'm just up the road from cosford if that one comes off so can collect all the stuff & deliver, maybe hitch a ride.

Any word from Alex? I'm heading over from birmingham way if anybody wants a lift.

 Did they say how long to get there Clive?

 Somehow i feel like a kid on christmas eve



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 5:27pm

Whats cheaper to insure her as for return, private yatch or old warboat company? Quoted £120 for lewina as private boat, not heard back off them for 506 & cant remember who it was. Obviously she'd be insured as company boat in malta due to liability.

Am i the first volunteer for crew?



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 5:45pm
Hi Sentley,

Doubt I'll be going to Malta again for the forseeable. That's my few days holiday used up.

Good 3rd party insurance won't be easy to get either.  We'll need to have her surveyed and we know they'll fail her until work done. Catch 22 again.  I'm afraid of what the bottom planking will cost to get repaired there and I don't know if a surveyor will pass a temp fix. I'll ask Joe Amato about what Malta will lett pass in a survey.

I'll check with the yard about letting someone work on her . I'll pm Alex about Sunday.

Regards

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: johnk
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 5:59pm

Hi all,

Just noting Northeastuser comments, hope someone in the mix can respond, not saying public necessarily, but unlike me, one of those who knows a bit about these things if I may say so.

John



Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 6:13pm

Sorry, I did not ask.

 Sentley has the mans details now., I shall not call him regarding this again, (too many cooks and all that) he may be interested in the engines when you get back though. ( he ships them to sri lanka for the tsunami relief to put in fishing boats)

  Is the plan to keep theese engines? if not is it worth spending money on them?

 



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: johnk
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 6:22pm

Hi,

Just remembered to have a look at the pictures, well, it's surprising how vessels can deteriorate from working with passengers to being neglected, I know full well not to judge from appearances, we would have run very far and fast ex MQ, although steel, she looked very much worse if you have a look at the photos. Any way, see how things pan out on slipping, wish you well with your second meeting, wish I had pitched up at the first in some ways, but better get the old paddler sorted first as I am chairman of it at the moment! however, keeping an eye on future projects and MAY be of use to you in other ways, things appearing to gather pace here in UK re historic ships, so if possible get her back to these shores and we can see.

John    



Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 6:26pm

Be nice to see some big diesels fitted to get her closer to original performance.

 Have to work with what we've got for the moment though. Rather have a fresh set of motors waiting before removing current ones but thats a while in the future.

 If we get some better performers it'd be nice to see them go to a good cause.

 Any room for 145 John?



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 6:30pm
Hi Clive,

I agree with Jimmy. The 3 engines will probably stay in her as she will be able to hit 10+ knots with all 3 running D.V.  We have no other options for the forseeable  as  'Big' engines will cost many thousands.

They just need a good service and they should be fine. 



 

-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?


Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 7:05pm

If she's back in original trim running harbour diesels maybe a manufacturer will 'sponsor' us some engines. Always better if they get some good visual pr from the start. If she's stripped to a hulk it could end up stuck like that.

 Did the yanks use the same tubes ect on the pt boats? Prob a better chance of them finding something like that. or i just weld up some replicas



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 7:09pm

he would buy them,, this would help pay for trip home.

   I am of the opinion, (careful)  that you should 'bite the bullet' and get her shipped, 20k is a lot of money but take off 4-5k fuel, 5-6k skipper+experienced crew, cost of gearbox+shipping/fitting 1k, temp repairs to hull? materials/ labour/ moorings £100pw? that is nearly 15k depending on how long it takes, not forgetting someone relyable to look after her when the liability shifts or travelling costs.

 I am not saying this will all be free in England but some labour will be free and repairs will be done only once, also insurance without a survey is unlikely and  what is the point of paying for that if you already know that he will say your boat has rot!

 When she is out of the water there wont be less soft planks than what you think- there will be a shed load more! that will add up to longer on the hard paying a shipwright.

I have used the word 'your' a lot and appreciate this is not my pigeon but this is my view form the outside so to speak, I hope I have not upset anyone, I'll go put my tin hat on!



-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: clive
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 7:14pm
I do agree with the engine thing, the fords should move her nicely wether 3 are neccessary is debateable. also cost of big engines as you say is silly money,

-------------
masbie something in the water.   www.freewebs.com/masb32/


Posted By: jimmy p
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 7:25pm

Fair comment Clive,

 Best thing is going to be working these things out when she's on the slip & quotes obtained. Could she be repaired in the timeframe on the slip?

Hoping that we can find an enthusiastic volunteer for the voyage home who just happens to be a qualified skipper. Any old navy boys out there with a couple of weeks spare? Wishful thinking but worth a try



-------------
A boat is a hole in the water surrounded by wood, into which one throws money


Posted By: marksaab
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 7:28pm

Hi All

Just to chip in on the engine front: these sites:

http://www.smedegaarden.net/starteng.htm - http://www.smedegaarden.net/starteng.htm

http://www.woods-group.co.uk/product_index.htm - http://www.woods-group.co.uk/product_index.htm

 

Do appear to offer potentially reasonable engines and other parts.

 

But certainly the biggest cost is going to be shipping, unless a consolidated shipment of all the parts, tools etc is made possibly using a whole 40ft container (containers are dirt cheap if you wanted your own), it would certainly save on shipping costs.

 

But for my two peneth shipping the boat to the UK seems the most sensible (low risk!) option.

 

Hope to meet you all on Sunday

 

Mark



-------------
Only yield when you must, never "give up the ship," but fight on to the last "with a stiff upper lip!"


Posted By: dgray
Date Posted: 23 February 2007 at 7:42pm
Hi All,

 With 2 engines and a clean bottom , 8-9 knots is expected. Adding the third has a couple of advantages.  If travelling under her own keel, we can make another 4 knots or so ( I hope) when needed.
If we keep seperate fuel tank for her we have a good backup engine if one other fails. We still can make the 8-9 knots.

Plus it will leave a very vey unusual wake!!

I'll try to speak to Kevin on Monday and ask him to ask  the yard/slip if they'll allow us to work on her when she's up. I doubt it though.  Still, can but ask.

Cheers


-------------
Don


Only a number, not even a name. How shall posterity hear of thy fame?



Print Page | Close Window